Does Florida Automatically Give 50/50 Custody? What Actually Changes It

On this page
No. Florida law presumes equal time-sharing is in your child's best interest, but that presumption can be rebutted. Since July 1, 2023, Florida Statute 61.13(2)(c)1 starts every case at equal time. A parent who wants a different schedule can still get one by proving it is more likely than not that equal time does not serve this child.
That one word, rebuttable, is what most articles leave out.
What does Florida's 50/50 presumption actually say?
Before July 2023, Florida had no presumption in favor of any schedule and none in favor of either parent. Judges started from a blank slate.
Today the slate starts at equal. The parent who wants something different carries the burden of showing why.
This is a starting point, not a decision. It is also not a ceiling or a floor. It is where the judge begins before hearing anything about your family.
What do I have to prove to get more than equal time?
You have to prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that equal time-sharing is not in your child's best interest.
Preponderance means more likely than not. It is the lowest standard of proof in civil law, and much easier to meet than the standards you have heard about from criminal cases. This is not proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and it is not clear and convincing evidence.
That is a real opening. It is not a free pass. Unless both parents agree on a schedule and the court approves it, the judge has to work through every factor in Florida Statute 61.13(3) and make written findings. Your evidence has to be concrete enough for a judge to write down.
One caveat worth knowing. Whether this presumption applies when you are asking to modify a parenting plan entered before July 1, 2023 is an open question that Florida courts are still working through. If your order predates the change, that is a conversation to have with a lawyer rather than an assumption to make.
Questions about your parenting plan? Call Leticia's office at 305-615-5533.
What actually convinces a judge to change the schedule?
Florida Statute 61.13(3) lists twenty best interest factors at subsections (a) through (t). A handful do most of the work.
Does the distance between our homes matter?
More than almost anything else. Factor (e) asks whether the parenting plan is geographically viable, with specific attention to school-age children and travel time.
A child who spends ninety minutes a day in a car to get to school is a real argument, and it says nothing bad about either parent. Measure the drive on a weekday morning, not on a Sunday afternoon. That number is often the whole case.
What if the other parent works nights or travels?
Courts look at how much of the time-sharing a parent would personally exercise, and how much would be handed to a nanny, a grandparent, or a new partner.
Shift work does not make someone a bad parent. But a schedule that gives equal time on paper and delivers substitute care in practice is a legitimate reason for a different arrangement. In South Florida this comes up constantly with hospital shifts, hospitality hours, and cruise and airline rotations.
What if the other parent will not cooperate?
Factor (a) asks whether each parent can encourage a close relationship with the other, honor the schedule, and be reasonable when changes come up.
Judges notice the parent who blocks calls, books activities during the other parent's time, or passes messages through the child. This factor cuts both ways, and it often decides close cases.
Safety issues, including domestic violence, substance abuse, and neglect, are the strongest grounds for a different schedule and are covered in a separate post.
What will not change a 50/50 schedule?
Being clear about this saves people months.
An affair. Moral fitness is a listed factor, but Florida courts want a connection between the conduct and an actual effect on the child.
One parent earning less. Neither parent's income is a best interest factor. The statute also says an equal time-sharing order does not stop a court from ordering child support.
Having been the primary caregiver. It is a factor. It is not by itself decisive.
Your child saying they want to live with you. There is no age in Florida at which a child chooses.
The other parent dating someone new. On its own, no.
How does this play out in Miami-Dade and Broward?
Geography carries more weight here than in most of the state, because the county is large and the traffic is predictable. Homestead to Weston on a school morning is not a schedule a judge has to be persuaded about. Crossing from south Miami-Dade into Broward before eight is the same story.
Both circuits handle a high volume of family cases, so specific, documented facts move faster than long narratives. A calendar showing eleven missed pickups does more than four hundred pages of text messages.
What should I do next?
- Measure both drives to school on a weekday morning and screenshot the times.
- Pull your child's school attendance record for the last two years.
- Export your co-parenting app history rather than screenshotting it.
- Build a dated calendar of every exchange that was late, missed, or changed.
- Write down both work schedules for a typical month, including rotations.
- Count the overnights your proposed schedule actually produces across a full year, holidays included.
Most parents arrive at a first meeting with a story and no documents. The parents who arrive with a folder are in a better position, and the difference is usually a few hours of work.
Talk it through
Every case turns on its own facts, and these factors interact in ways that are hard to predict from the outside. To talk about your situation and what a realistic schedule looks like, call the firm at 305-615-5533 to schedule a consultation.

Leticia Dieppa, Esq.
Founder of Dieppa Legal · Florida Supreme Court Certified Family Mediator
Leticia Dieppa, Esq., Florida Bar No. 91015, is the founder of Dieppa Legal, a family law practice on Coral Way in Miami, and a Florida Supreme Court Certified Family Mediator. She represents parents in time-sharing and parenting plan matters in Miami-Dade and Broward counties and is frequently appointed as guardian ad litem.
This post is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Florida law changes, and how these rules apply depends on the facts of your case.
